The concept of remaking songs has been around for a long time and has worked for many songs. However, over time, this concept has become repetitive, and fans no longer enjoy listening to fast-tempo versions of songs they once loved.
In their pursuit of making their listeners enjoy the music they release; music producers have once again managed to displease their audiences with their latest rendition of ‘Pasoori’. This is not the first time a song remake has sparked public anger, and it appears that it won’t be the last either.
For the last few years, followers of Bollywood music have voiced their criticisms about the fading authenticity and energy of the genre. These new renditions of older popular songs have only further provoked their discontent and dissatisfaction, and it seems that directors and producers have yet to fully grasp the audience’s reactions.
Pasoori Released, Remade, Rejected?
The Coke Studio song performed by Pakistani singers Ali Sethi and Shae Gill gained global acclaim and became a sensation worldwide. The vibrant song not only captivated the hearts of people in India but also served as a unifying force between India and Pakistan, thanks to the power of the internet. It found its place in the hearts of people in India, and it kept everyone hooked for months after its release.
Official Coke Studio Album Cover; Image Source: Wikipedia
The remake of the song for ‘Satyaprem ki Katha,’ featuring Kartik Aryan and Kiara Advani, has caused disappointment among fans from both India and Pakistan. The original song’s lyrics conveyed a heartfelt expression of longing for someone who is far away and the pain of being separated from them. This context has left fans confused as to why the remake is being used to portray a love story that unites the two characters in the film. Furthermore, the overall lyrics of the song fail to capture the essence and brilliance of the original masterpiece, further adding to the dissatisfaction of the fans.
Other Popular Remakes
It’s important to remember that not all remakes are disliked, as some manage to strike the right balance between paying homage to the original and adding a fresh perspective. For example, Kishore Kumar, Sumit Kumar, and Vishal Dadlani’s 2008 version of ‘Bachna Ae Haseeno’ was a sensation upon its release and continues to be enjoyed by people singing along whenever it plays.
A Still from the song; Image Source: Yash Raj Films
Similarly, ‘Aapka Kya Hoga Janabe Ali’ from the 2010 comedy film ‘Housefull’ and Darshan Raval’s rendition of ‘Ek Ladki Ko Dekha Toh Aisa Laga’ has also found a special place in the public’s heart even after several years since their release.
However, the number of remakes that have been well-liked by the majority is relatively small compared to those that have received widespread criticism. Songs like ‘The Humma Song’, ‘Muqabla’, ‘Coca Cola’, ‘Masakali’, and many others have left fans of the original version questioning the need for their remakes.
Adding rap tracks or modern elements to these classics seems unnecessary and has not been popular with fans thus far.
The Reasons Behind the Dislike
There are various reasons why people dislike song remakes. Many listeners have a strong attachment to the original version of a song. The nostalgia associated with the original composition, along with the emotions and memories it evokes, creates a deep connection for the audience. When a remake is introduced, it can be perceived as an attempt to alter or tamper with something that holds sentimental value, leading to disappointment and resistance from fans. Furthermore, song remakes sometimes fail to capture the essence and authenticity of the original, which fans view as a deliberate attempt to tamper with something dear to their hearts.
In conclusion, the discontent towards song remakes often stems from a strong attachment to the original version and a perception that the remake fails to capture the essence and authenticity of the original composition.